Reprints     Printer-Friendly    Email this Article    RSS        Font Size     What's This?

[Pease Porridge]

What's All This Penny Stuff, Anyhow?



Bob Pease  |   ED Online ID #12978  |   August 3, 2006

Article Rating:

A friend wrote to me to complain about a new proposal to lock out individual Internet users. It seems like the issue is costs versus access. Big companies would be able to send and receive e-mails faster and cheaper than individuals. If this plan comes closer to reality, I will complain more vigorously.

"I don't usually write to congressmen, but I do when it's important. Right now, I'm not sure this is important. Not yet," I replied to my friend.

"I would not mind paying a penny for every e-mail I send. I would even pay, reimburse, my company, NSC, a penny for every personal message I send," I continued. "In the last two months, I have sent over 1000 e-mails, and let's say half are personal. Would I change my e-mail habits if I had to pay $2.50 per month? Heck, no. I spend more than that on stamps."

I wouldn't even mind paying a penny for every search I do. I mean, every search I make takes away several seconds of my life as I wait for the results. So I don't search for things lightly.

By the way, I did find some things in a recent search that weren't there a year ago. I usually use dogpile.com, but I must admit, google.com did find the lyrics to Shango's "Day After Day (It's Slippin' Away)" when Dogpile did not. "What can we do with a bushel of wet gold?" the group sang in 1969, when the song hit #57 on the national charts.

I would be delighted if all the spammers had to pay a penny per message. That might cut them back a lot. I'd vote for that. I won't approve of any volume discounts for them. And, a penny per megabyte per addressee would seem fair. Why would we protect the pigs who clutter up the airwaves? (Or, okay, wires.)

You're familiar with the idea that some people wouldn't stoop to pick up a penny. But picking up pennies, one per second, even if I had to stoop separately for each one, could pay me $36 per hour—and that's not bad wages. Furthermore, these are pennies with no tax, so each one would be worth 1.7 cents or so. So, pennies aren't trivial.

Nor is my time trivial. I could save a few pennies per day if I drive slower, but that would waste a few minutes a day. I am holding at 65 mph as a reasonable compromise. I used to drive at 68 mph, and I will again if gas gets below $2.99. But I am jealous of my time.

As for computing access, I think this proposal is dumb. Somebody will squash it, sooner or later. I already have highspeed access when I'm at work. My company pays for it. When I'm at home, I have a mediocre slow modem, but that's okay with me. Most people who aren't willing to pay for a lot of fast access get slow, cheap access. That's okay with me too. I can't see a big deal about what you pay and what you can get. I don't think that's a real problem.

TYPING TRICKS
I just used my left thumb on the space bar— which is contrary to good typing practice. But when your right hand is doing several other tasks, backspace and end, it may be okay.

Did you see in my column that many computer guys make @ by hitting the shift key with their left little finger and reaching over to the 2 key with their right index finger (ELECTRONIC DESIGN, Aug. 4, 2005, p. 20)? I must say, I do. I can do it the other way, but it is a forced deal.

Hey, do you know what's funny? My stupid computer has locked up (for 45 seconds) about once every 20 minutes for the last week. And I just noticed that it has stopped doing that. That sure is fine with me. I have tried a dozen tricks. I also have asked several computer experts to help. They tried, but it did no good. Now, it seems to have gotten better at a random time, and for no good reason. (Merde.)




Reprints     Printer-Friendly    Email this Article    RSS        Font Size     What's This?


  • A New Design Inflection Point
  • Forecasting Industry Growth For 2009 And Beyond
  • EDA Retools To Exploit Multicore Architectures
  • Design And Verification Move Up In Abstraction
  • EDA Retools To Exploit Multicore Architectures
  • A New Design Inflection Point
  • Design And Verification Move Up In Abstraction
  • Challenges Lurk For 22-nm Physical Implementation
    1) 1-A Switching Regulators Operate With 96% Efficiency To Replace Linear Regulators
    (489 views today)
    2) Build A Smart Battery Charger Using A Single-Transistor Circuit
    (310 views today)
    3) Battery Pack Improves Li-Ion Management For Electric Vehicles
    (299 views today)
    4) New Power Approaches May Fuel Analog Job Opportunities In Security And Health Applications
    (290 views today)
    5) Step-Down Switching Regulator Provides 60-V Input Transient Protection
    (143 views today)
    ALL TOP 20







    Reader Comments

    Frankly, I'm surprised that someone in technology is even supports a penny fee for e-mails and searches. Why should corporations be able to have better, faster internet access than individuals? I have better internet access at home than work. And why shouldn't I? I do far more internet surfing at home than at work. I would NOT like to spend a few bucks a month on e-mails and searches. I already pay for high-speed internet access. Internet searches for me are practically instantaneous, so that's typically the first thing I do when looking for information. As for the spammers, paying a penny per e-mail won't do a darn thing to prevent it. Most of the spammers are the same corporations that spend $2 million for a 30-second Super Bowl commercial (a penny would be a bargain).

    aarond -August 25, 2006   (Article Rating: )

    Frankly, I'm surprised that someone in technology is even supports a penny fee for e-mails and searches. Why should corporations be able to have better, faster internet access than individuals? I have better internet access at home than work. And why shouldn't I? I do far more internet surfing at home than at work. I would NOT like to spend a few bucks a month on e-mails and searches. I already pay for high-speed internet access. Internet searches for me are practically instantaneous, so that's typically the first thing I do when looking for information. As for the spammers, paying a penny per e-mail won't do a darn thing to prevent it. Most of the spammers are the same corporations that spend $2 million for a 30-second Super Bowl commercial (a penny would be a bargain).

    aarond -August 25, 2006   (Article Rating: )

    This is one of many ideas floated to deal with spam that sounds good but won't work and/or has bad side effects.

    One reason that it won't work is there is no practical way to collect the "postage". The obvious approach is to collect it when sent. But then spammers will use (if they aren't already), mail servers located in other countries. Even easier, a spammer could just set up his own mail server and collect from himself.

    One bad side effect is that it would put many newsletters out of business. I subscribe to several that have fairly large distribution lists. A penny an email to send a monthly newsletter to 50,000 subscribers would add up. And yes, I'd be willing to pay my share, after all, a monthly newsletter would be only 12 cents a year. But the mechanism to collect this toll would cost more than that. Consider the burden for church groups, local athletic leagues, etc if they had to cope with this. I don't think that there is a price point high enough to discourage spammers and low enough to avoid this impact.

    Fred Langa (http://www.langa.com) has talked about this and other schemes in his column. You might try searching his site for insight.

    Charlie B -August 06, 2006
    Read more comments...

    POST YOUR COMMENTS HERE

    Name:

    Email:
    Rate this article:

     less useful more useful 
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    Your Comments:

    Enter the text from the image below




    Please refresh the page if you have trouble reading this text.
     
     

    PartFinder

    Find real-time pricing, stock status, same-day/next-day shipping options and more. Brought to you by Digi-Key. Go to PartFinder.    
    GlobalSpec

    PART SEARCH :
    Powered by: GlobalSpec - The Engineering Search Engine
    Sponsored Links

    Electronic Design Europe Electronic Design China EEPN Power Electronics Auto Electronics Microwaves & RF
    Mobile Dev & Design Schematics Find Power Products Military Electronics EE Events Related Resources