[EEPN In Electronic Design]
Get The Right Power Supply To Tackle Peaks And Valleys
Ken Peterson
ED Online ID #18139
February 28, 2008
Copyright © 2006 Penton Media, Inc., All rights reserved. Printing of this document is for personal use only.
Reprints
A power supply with high
peak-current capability
can support loads that are
higher than the nominal
continuous power for short periods of time,
without the unit shutting down or damage
occurring. Typical constraints on this
capability include time (duration of the
current peak) and the percentage of time
the supply must support the higher load
(duty cycle).
Products often requiring high peak current
include print heads, pumps, motors,
and disk drives, found in abundance in factory
automation, medical pumping systems,
fluid and material handling, robotics,
power tools, machining, packaging, test,
dispensing systems, and printers.
Anticipated growth in these sectors indicates
a growing need for power supplies
that can support short-duration high-peak
loads. Such units must also be environmentally
friendly and efficient. There are significant
benefits to utilizing power supplies
capable of supporting high peak loads.
First, designers may use a smaller supply,
reducing overall system size and weight. In
a system needing 800 W for a short duration,
a 400-W unit with an 800-W peak
will generally mean a smaller footprint.
Second, the lower-power, high-peak unit
will cost less. Again, if you need 400 W
continuous but there is a short 800-W peak,
rather than using a more expensive 800-W
supply, a 400-W unit with an 800-W peak may be more cost-effective. To realize these
benefits, it is important to define your system
with respect to some variables: peak
current, duration of peak current, frequency
of peak current events (duty cycle), and
anticipated power requirements during
non-peak current demand (Fig. 1).
There are ways of estimating some of
these values and deriving them based on
the characteristics of the supply. For applications
with peak current requirements, a
simple evaluation of the proposed systems’
power budget can help minimize both the
size and cost of the system. Properly profiling
the power requirement will lead to an
optimal solution.
However, there are potential pitfalls.
Some supplies described as supporting high
peak loads may not actually provide the
anticipated benefits. Digging deeper into a
manufacturer’s data sheet may be necessary
to understand how the performance characteristics
relate to the specific application.
PEAK LOAD CAPABILITY
Typically, there are three methods for characterizing
peak load capability. One common
characterization entails testing a supply
for a short duration (up to 30 seconds is
not unusual) at a duty cycle of 10% to 15%
and at a peak load just below the overcurrent
protection (OCP) cutoff, usually 12% to
20% above the continuous current rating.
Essentially, this is an off-the-shelf supply,
characterized to infer a safety margin or headroom over and
above the nominal continuous
rating. In practice,
this may provide a false
feeling of security. Although
some applications may
require an additional
12% to 20% of power
for short durations,
most motors, pumps,
and print heads, for
example, demand much
higher current for a shorter
duration.
A second practice characterizes the
supply with a very high peak, up to 200%
of nominal, but for such a short duration
that the OCP circuit cannot detect or react
to the overcurrent condition. Some data
sheets specify peak-current handling based
on what the power supply can withstand for
500 µs via this characterization scheme.
Based on this, a 300-W supply can operate
at 600 W for 500 µs, but must operate
at less than 300 W through a nonpeak
period. While this is a common way
to characterize power supplies, very few
applications require 200% nominal power
for such short durations.
The third characterization method specifies
the peak rating at high-line, meaning
with a greater than 180-V ac input. In this
example, a 400-W supply may be able to
provide 600 W of continuous power with an
input voltage greater than 180 V ac—a real
benefit when high-line ac input is available.
Continue to page 2
Globally, there is such an array of potential
input voltages that this benefit is nice
to have. But it may restrict the sale of a system
to countries where low-line ac input is
predominant, or at least encountered on a
regular basis.
Power supplies specifically groomed
with high peak capabilities in mind use
an overall design and architecture, OCP
circuitry, energy storage characteristics,
efficiency, and thermal robustness that will
support high peak loads. Such units may
be able to deliver up to twice their nominal
power for 10 s, which is a realistic application
requirement. Furthermore, this capability
may extend to duty cycles that range
from 35% to 50%.
One approach along these lines is to use
a power supply that provides dc-output
modularity. A modular design enables the
user to specify several standard outputs
alongside one that provides the necessary high peak current
capability. In other
words, you aren’t
likely to need a high
peak capability
on
every output, so look
for a power system that avoids
the need to pay for that (Fig. 2).
WORKING OUT THE NUMBERS
Important factors to determine when
selecting a power supply for a high peak
application include how much power can
be drawn during the non-peak duration,
how much peak power can be provided,
and how long the peak power can be
drawn. The answers to these questions are
constrained by the rated specification of
the power supply.
For example, the specification of a
400-W power supply that can provide 800
W of peak power for up to 10 s at a 35%
duty cycle defines the operating envelope
within which your requirements must fall.
Using these specifications, you can determine
that the available power during the
non-peak duration will be approximately
180 W. If you know your application won’t
require more than 720 W at peak and for
5 s or less and the duty cycle is 25%, then
you can draw about 290 W during the nonpeak
duration.
Once you’re satisfied that your design
requirement does not exceed the power
supply’s rated specification, the systemlevel
questions arise. For instance, you may
need to establish how much power can be
drawn during the non-peak duration if the
peak is less than the power supply’s peak
rating or what duty cycle can be achieved if
the peak power is drawn for less than the
power supply’s rated duration. The math is
not complex, but you do need to account
for all these system level issues to ensure
trouble-free power-supply operation.
|