[Pease Porridge]
What's All This AMT Stuff, Anyhow? (Part 2)
Bob Pease
ED Online ID #18511
April 10, 2008
Copyright © 2006 Penton Media, Inc., All rights reserved. Printing of this document is for personal use only.
Reprints
I’ve often heard that if you’re going to owe the Alternative
Minimum Tax, there’s nothing you can do about
it. And that makes me scream! Most of these officious
statements say you can postpone some income and
defer the AMT, but you’ll just pay them next year. “There’s
nothing you can do to avoid the AMT.” It’s a lie!
I was absent-mindedly reading some of the boilerplate on
some of my other investments. “You might like to buy some
AMT-free bonds,” Dreyfus said. I instantly perked up my ears
and investigated. I’ve looked up some Dreyfus funds, and I am
also checking into Citicorp, “Black Rock,” and Fidelity.
It’s true that these bonds may pay a lower rate than conventional
bonds, but that is not a big deal. It’s also apparently true
that there aren’t any (at this time) AMT-free bond funds that
are California-only, and thus entirely free of federal and state
taxes and the AMT. But I don’t mind paying some taxes, so
long as I can start to get out of paying so much AMT.
ACCORDING TO MY GUY...
My friend in the stockbroker business says he can avoid the
AMT as well as state and federal taxes by buying a specific
bond issued in California. (Whatever state you live in, do your
homework.) To do this, you may have to make a $5000 minimum
initial investment. I mean, I don’t mind paying my fair
share of taxes, but the AMT rates are absurd, with hardly any
fair deductions or exemptions permitted.
For example, after I pay my state taxes, my ordinary 1040
federal gross taxable income (line 38) would be improved by
deducting those state taxes. But the AMT forces me to pay
federal (AMT) taxes on my state taxes. That’s not fair.
The 6251 form indicates that you just pay a 28% tax rate, but
that’s another lie. After you put in the surtax multipliers, the
incremental tax rate can go above 44%, and the base exemption
is only about $66,000 for a joint return. You can get shafted real
fast by the AMT—not to mention that you can get ruined by
other obscure, hidden, unfair tax rates as high as 85% per the
Social Security benefits worksheet.
Specifically, you don’t just add and “combine” the data on lines
1-27 on line 28 of form 6251. If your income is above 207.5k,
you take the total that should go on line 28, multiply the excess
over 207.5k by 25%, and put that into line 28, so every $1000
increase in your income can cause a $1250 increase in taxable
income on line 28. (This would normally require another worksheet,
but the AMT guys want things to look simple.)
Further, as your income increases, your exemptions (on
the page 7 worksheet) decrease, so your taxable income goes
up again by another $312.50. Then, down at the deductions
worksheet, this $1000 increase, too, is multiplied up by –(–3%),
so you are paying a “28%” tax on $1592. It results in a $446
increase in your taxes, for a 44.6% tax rate—and that is before
you start paying state income taxes. (Does your state have an
AMT state tax, too? Lucky you!)
WHAT TO DO?
If you do a Web search for AMT-free bonds, you can start
learning. Ask for a prospectus. Obviously, I can not recommend
any particular fund. But I have invested some of my long-term
retirement funds in these AMT-free bond funds. Note that
books and magazine articles keep saying that you can’t avoid
the AMT, and I am absolutely fed up with their lies!
If you got advice on how to avoid AMT on your investments,
you read it here, not there. I bought a couple of big $30
tax books published by Lasser and by Ernst & Young. They
claim “We’ll tell you things the IRS doesn’t want you to know.”
But they don’t tell you one word about AMT-free bond funds.
Ahem. I puke in their lousy, lying briefcases.
If you are at all skeptical, just add an extra $1000 to your
income, run that through your computerized tax program
(or your tax expert), and see how your tax changes. Plug
another $1000 into your capital gains, and see how that
changes things—especially in your AMT. Surprise! Have
you seen your 2007 tax forms yet? As I write this, I have not
seen mine.
Maybe you can print yours at www.irs.gov. But the mailman
will just barely bring yours, in the nick of time, because Congress
was so slow to settle this AMT matter in December, and
its members aren’t happy about being forced to make decisions
on tax law that will make so many people unhappy.
You don’t have to be rich to get shafted by the AMT. Just
sell a little stock, or receive some capital gains. I haven’t done all
the math, but a lot of taxpayers will be very unhappy when they
learn that they have to pay thousands of dollars of extra taxes.
And they, too, will be furious about being lied to.
The AMT is not going to be reformed or indexed properly
anytime soon, because doing so would cause the loss of many
hundreds of billions of dollars of revenue. And nobody can
figure out how to plan any reforms, as they can’t imagine how
to replace all that revenue.
*See part 1 at www.electronicdesign.com, ED Online 11374.
Comments invited! rap@galaxy.nsc.com —or:
Mail Stop D2597A, National Semiconductor
P.O. Box 58090, Santa Clara, CA 95052-8090
|