[Technology Report]
Wending Our Way From Wired To Wireless
We're still a heavily wired society, but today's trends look to make it a truly wireless world.
Louis E. Frenzel
ED Online ID #19053
June 19, 2008
Copyright © 2006 Penton Media, Inc., All rights reserved. Printing of this document is for personal use only.
Reprints
Over the past century,
we’ve wired and
rewired the world
countless times, evolving
from copper cable
to fiber optics and
beyond. But this cycle
will soon come to an
end as rapid-fire wireless innovations consistently
deliver faster, cheaper, and more reliable
communication.
ONE TREND AT A TIME
The telephone business is still mostly wired,
but the cell-phone phenomenon continues to
chip it away. The balance may in fact shift drastically,
now that cellular service has passed wired
phone service in terms of number of subscribers.
And let’s not forget the wired to cordless phone
movement inside the home. I’ve never seen any
figures, but I would guess that more than half of
all home phones are cordless.
The next frontier in communications, computer
networking movement, began in the 1970s
with wired systems. Long-distance networking
used domestic telephone lines with 300- and
1200-baud modems and special “fast” dedicated
56-kbit/s lines. Local-area networks (LANs)
were invented later. Ethernet came along in
1973 using the large RG-8/U coax cable, which
was followed by smaller cables like RG-58/U.
Finally, unshielded twisted pair (UTP) first
served as telephone wire before improved versions
like CAT5 and CAT6 became the norm.
The LAN trend is now wireless. It started with
the 802.11 standard in the 1990s, but didn’t
take off until 802.11b arrived around 1997.
Quickly after that, we got the faster 11a and
11g versions. Today, the super-fast 11n version
dominates.
Wired Ethernet networks haven’t disappeared,
they just got faster—first 100
Mbits/s, then 1 Gbit/s, and today reaching
10 Gbits/s. The faster versions consist
of fiber, though wireless is still the trend.
As enterprise networks expand, the extensions
are wireless for greater flexibility and
convenience. Work continues within the
IEEE for even faster wireless LAN links.
Wireless reigns in home networks. Early
home net adopters went for UTP Ethernet
and other wired technologies like cable TV
coax, powerline, and phone-line systems.
Some of them are still around, but better
than 80% of all home PC networks use
Wi-Fi. While 11n can deliver up to about
300 Mbits/s over 100 m in a home or
enterprise environment, a faster version
beyond 1 Gbit/s is the goal.
Incidentally, Wi-Fi gave us something
else: broadband wireless access through
hotspots. When we’re in hotels, airports,
cafes, convention centers, and other public
places, we can easily connect to the
Internet for e-mail and other applications
with our laptops. You can even connect via a
cell-phone plug-in card in your laptop. All laptops
today come with Wi-Fi built in, and soon many
will include WiMAX, making broadband wireless
available in most major cities.
Wired remains solid in metropolitan-area networks
(MANs) and wide-area networks (WANs),
which are mostly fiber anyway (see “Wired Won’t
Go Down Without A Fight” at www.electronicdesign.com, ED Online 19068). Fiber is super-fast,
and lots of unlit fiber is still available. Fiber networks
will continue to form the backbone of our
connectivity, especially to the Internet.
But wireless trends are making their mark
within MANs. Wireless links using microwave
and free-space optical systems are already in
use. Even faster links should emerge as equipment
is developed for the millimeter bands.
And consider the most common wired MAN
of all—the cable TV network. Its main distribution
uses fiber and then drops to homes by
coax. Most homes get their TV by cable, and
most high-speed broadband Internet access
in the U.S. hooks up via cable systems. Now
we’re seeing WiMAX broadband wireless technology
begin to attack this market.
WiMAX promises a high-speed wireless
Internet connection to rival cable TV and DSL
services as carriers like Clearwire, Sprint
Nextel, and TowerStream roll out their new
systems. WiMAX won’t kill the wired systems, but it brings needed competition, and rural
areas with no broadband service can join the
21st century. We may even get Internet Protocol
Television (IPTV) this way.
The cell-phone world was all voice until the
late 1990s and early 2000s. That’s when data
services and the so-called 2.5G period arrived.
GPRS was added to GSM TDMA phones, and
1xRTT was added to cdma2000 phones. EDGE
and EV-DO came later with higher speeds.
Since then, we’ve moved into the 3G era with
WCDMA on GSM networks, which have been
further updated with EDGE and HSDPA/HSUPA/
HSPA+. In the cdma2000 world (EV-DO), Rev.
A has been added. Future 4G services will use
Long Term Evolution (LTE) and, less likely, Ultra
Mobile Broadband (Fig. 1). WiMAX will see a
parallel path worldwide, though it isn’t expected
to play a role in cell-phone service in the U.S.
Consider another cellular trend. Today, more
than 200,000 of the cell-phone sites in the
U.S. use a wired backhaul system to the main
telephone system. That technology, the popular
T1 digital line, carries 24 calls. Increasing subscriber
capacity and expanding cell-phone data
use requires more and faster backhaul.
Continue on Page 2
To solve that problem, more expensive
leased T1 lines and even faster T3 (44-Mbit/s)
lines were added. Even ATM (asynchronous
transfer mode) and fiber have been used in a
few places. Beyond that, engineers have looked
at microwave backhaul and fiber.
In the future, wireless backhaul will expand.
But the real solution may lie in the use of
Ethernet and Internet Protocol (IP) backhaul,
including the use of multiprotocol label switching
(MPLS) to provide quality of service (QoS)
over the IP networks. That could be either wired
or wireless. In any case, backhaul is one of the
most critical issues for cell-phone carriers.
The industrial networking world is making the
shift to wireless as well. Because of reliability
and maintenance issues, wireless has never
been too popular in connecting sensors to control
systems and in connecting end actuators
(motors, pumps, solenoids, etc.) to the system.
Today, though, wireless solutions are more reliable
and secure than ever.
Industrial networks are widely adopting Wi-Fi,
plus wireless sensor technology like ZigBee.
Also, mesh networks help to interconnect a
wide range of sensors and extend the system’s
range and reliability. All sorts of wireless links,
both proprietary and standard, are replacing the
older wired industrial networks using Modbus,
the Profibus Device bus, HART, and dozens of
other technologies.
Machine-to-machine (M2M) wireless has grown
along these same lines. M2M uses the cellular
system to implement an enormous range of
monitoring and control functions in virtually every
industry (Fig. 2). Tiny GSM or CDMA cell-phone
transceivers are buried inside truck fleets and
cargo carriers for asset tracking. They also monitor
remote tank farms, connect to security systems,
and monitor vending machines.
M2M has been one of the most “silent” wireless
movements, but it’s growing by double-digit
percentages every year. The applications seem
to be endless, and costs continue to drop.
MAKING IT HAPPEN
Certainly, the wired to wireless movement will
march on. Within that trend, at any given time,
the wireless world is in transition from one technology
to another or from an older technology
to an improved technology. Buried even further
within those shifts is the never-ending quest for
higher data rates. While security and QoS are
still part of the change, nothing else matters as
much as speed in all segments of wireless.
Technology developments like orthogonal frequency-
division multiplexing (OFDM), multiple-input
multiple-output (MIMO), and software-defined
radio (SDR), as well as regulatory conditions,
have smoothed the path from wired to wireless.
OFDM is a modulation technique that takes
a high-speed serial data signal, divides it into
multiple slower data streams, and uses them to
modulate many adjacent narrow channels over a
broad bandwidth. The modulation on each channel
is usually binary phase-shift keying (BPSK),
quadrature phase-shift keying (QPSK), or some
quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM) variant.
The result is a very broadband signal that’s
very spectrally efficient, producing very high bit/
hertz rates. Because the signal is spread over a
wide band, it’s also more tolerant of multipath
cancellation and fading, which is a common
problem in microwave frequencies. And, OFDM
can be adapted to create an efficient access
method (orthogonal frequency-division multiple
access, or OFDMA) for many subscribers in the
same band. OFDM is so good that it is gradually
replacing most other more traditional wireless
methods, including the vaunted CDMA spreadspectrum
method.
The fastest Wi-Fi standards all use OFDM,
with 802.11a/g producing data rates to 54
Mbits/s in a 20-MHz band. The broadband wireless
standard WiMAX (802.16) is also OFDM
(Fig. 3). 3GPP’s forthcoming LTE 4G cell-phone
standard is based on OFDM as well. The most
common form of short-range Ultra Wideband
(UWB) networking, WiMedia, is based on OFDM.
Broadcast HDRadio uses OFDM. All mobile TV
technologies for cell phones (MediaFLO, DVB-H,
etc.) are based on a coded OFDM.
Another technique that’s helping push
wireless, MIMO, uses multiple transceivers
and antennas on the same band to transmit
different and coded parallel data streams
to enable faster and more reliable wireless
services. It has been adopted in the latest
802.11n Wi-Fi, as well as in forthcoming
WiMAX applications. LTE also provides for
a MIMO component. The overall result is
greater data speeds and better link reliability
under multipath conditions.
To make both OFDM and MIMO practical,
SDR techniques are applied. SDR replaces traditional
wireless circuits with software on DSPs
or DSP-programmed FPGAs. OFDM and MIMO
aren’t possible with older wireless circuits, but
both are easier with DSP.
Continue on Page 3
Wireless standards have also aided the
wired to wireless transition. Today, every wireless
technology is established by a standard.
The biggest contributor in this department, the
IEEE, has standardized Wi-Fi (802.11), WiMAX
(802.16), and other short-range wireless technologies
like the personal-area-networking (PAN)
standards for Bluetooth (803.15.3), ZigBee
(802.15.4), and many others.
Both the 3GPP and 3GPP2 set cell-phone standards.
Each group also develops standards that
are ultimately adopted by the ITU. For instance,
3GPP developed the GSM, GPRS, EDGE, WCDMA,
and now the LTE standards, while 3GPP2 handles
cdma2000, 1xRTT, EV-DO, and UMB.
Standards provide interoperability between
products of different companies. The related
industry forums, alliances, and consortia
ensure this interoperability with certification
testing. While proprietary wireless technologies
do occasionally succeed in niche markets,
the largest adoption comes when firm
national or international standards exist.
Spectrum availability certainly plays into the
wireless phenomenon. The electromagnetic
spectrum is finite, and it ultimately could
limit the wireless transition. Countries
regulate the spectrum and allocate it
to various standards and services.
In highly developed areas like
Europe, Asia, and the U.S., spectrum
is scarce.
But thanks to technology with
greater spectral efficiency, advances are being made. Pushing into the higher
frequencies like the millimeter bands (30 to 300
GHz) gives us even more spectrum to use. The
mm bands are tougher to deal with, but again,
semiconductor technology advances are giving
us devices that perpetuate the wireless trend.
In the U.S., the Federal Communications
Commission is phasing out the older UHF TV
spectrum from 698 to 806 MHz. Known as the
700-MHz band, this spectrum was recently auctioned
off for new wireless services. Most of it
will be used for expanded cell-phone services
with faster data capabilities, such as those available
from LTE. WiMAX will get new spectrum,
as will the new broadcast mobile TV services
that are just beginning (see “Some Interesting
Wireless Trends,” Drill Deeper 19069).
WHAT WE NEVER HAD BEFORE
Perhaps no other aspect of the wired to wireless
transition has benefited more than personal
and business communications. Of course,
spearheading it all is the cell phone. Research
firm ABI says that “as mobile usage in business
grows, it challenges the value of fixed-line
communications.” Today, the cell-phone business
dominates wireless, both commercial and
personal. Data services like texting, e-mail, and
Internet access continue to grow at double-digit
rates, and projections show that it will eventually
exceed voice in most carriers’ networks.
GPS navigation and other location technologies
have no doubt added a new dimension to
the cell-phone age. With a GPS receiver and
increasingly with our cell phones, we can immediately
find where we are. Also, emergency services
can find us thanks to the E911 capability
built into every new phone. With reliable navigation
and location technology, new locationbased
services are expected to flourish.
Some phones use internal GPS receivers with
assistance from nearby cell sites (called
Assisted-GPS) to pinpoint a handset location.
Other handsets use a triangulation method with
three nearby cell sites to locate a handset.
Called uplink-time difference of arrival (U-TDOA),
this method doesn’t require an internal GPS
receiver. A newer hybrid approach from
TruePosition combines the A-GPS and U-TDOA
methods with new algorithms to greatly improve
location accuracy to less than 25 m.
|