[Lab Bench]
DSP Pumps Up The Performance In High-End Stereo Speakers
William Wong
ED Online ID #19278
July 10, 2008
Copyright © 2006 Penton Media, Inc., All rights reserved. Printing of this document is for personal use only.
Reprints
Even in this age of tiny earbud music players,
audiophiles want high-end stereo systems
that provide perfect acoustics and fidelity—
and technology is making these systems less
expensive than ever. In fact, I recently received a letter from a
reader asking about some of these developments:
“I heard that Emerald Physics has a set of $3500 speakers
that outperforms more expensive, $20k to $50k systems using
a DSP. Is this possible?” asked S. Brown.
DSP IN THE MIDDLE
To get the answer, I talked with Clayton Shaw, president of
Emerald Physics. His company’s $3500 CS2 system includes
a set of open-baffle speakers combined with a Behringer
DCX2496 Ultradrive Pro that sits between your preamp and a
set of four amplifiers that drive the speakers (see the figure).
The DCX2496’s 32-bit Sharc DSP from Analog Devices
implements an eighth-order digital filter network that Emerald
Physics uses for active crossover support in addition to
adjusting frequency, phase and time linearization, and lowfrequency
(LF) equalization to deliver optimum audio performance
from 20 Hz to 22 kHz.
The DSP performs these tasks to make up for the differences
in performance between all the components in the system.
Each speaker has a pair of 4-O, 380-mm, low- to mid-frequency
woofer drivers operating below 1 kHz to handle vocals
and large instruments and an 8-O, 25-mm exit compression
driver. The speakers are placed 3 to 7 ft from the wall because
reflectivity plays an important part in audio quality.
The DCX2496’s algorithms account for the position information,
the amplifier characteristics, and the speaker characteristics.
This is more difficult than it sounds because different
amplifier pairs may be used with the system, and each type of
speaker has different response characteristics.
The non-linear characteristics and distortion that can be
added would result in a lower-quality playback. Signals routed
to the low-frequency and high-frequency speakers normally go
through a crossover system. The crossover point is where the
differences of the speakers and amplifiers have the most effect.
The active crossover is set at 1 kHz. The system employs
a Linkwitz-Riley filter also known as a Butterworth squared
filter. Presets allow easy configuration by even non-technical
audiophiles, though techies are free to tweak parameters.
DOWN THE AUDIO STREAM
The audio stream passing through the DCX2496’s 24-bit
analog-to-digital converters (ADCs) and digital-to-analog
converters (DACs) is then modified so resulting wavefronts
are in synch for the listener. This controlled directivity is harder
to accomplish than you might think because of the nonlinearity
of the components across the spectrum, including changes
in dispersion patterns. For example, low-range output tends to
be more omnidirectional while compression drivers and waveguides
handling the upper end are more directional.
The precise reproduction of the original sound is why audiophiles
will pay so much for speakers and amplifiers that can
deliver this level of quality. It allows us to hear subtle nuances
that would otherwise become background noise.
When it comes to manipulating the audio stream in the
time domain, it’s easier to use the DSP than a passive crossover
system. The DSP also allows a range of techniques to be
applied to the stream so adjustments are made in a number of
areas, delivering controlled directivity.
The CS2’s patent-pending controlled directivity applies to
a wider range of speaker architectures. Its big advantage is its
ability to provide consistent and realistic output regardless of
room configuration. It also can deliver a binaural effect if the
speakers are angled toward the center, though this can only be
done with a very accurate tuned waveguide system.
In the future, a move to all-digital operation will eliminate
the need for the DCX2496’s ADCs and DACs. However, systems
will still require Emerald Physics’ compensation support
because of the remaining components within the system. In
any case, analog rules the high end where amplifiers use vacuum
tubes because of distortion and stability issues.
ANALOG DEVICES • www.analog.com
BEHRINGER • www.behringer.com
EMERALD PHYSICS • www.emeraldphysics.com
|