Wireless PAN Alternatives To Bluetooth

June 24, 2002
In case you're still weighing the alternatives, take a look at these wireless technologies competing with Bluetooth in the personal area network (PAN) space: Induction Wireless: This technique uses magnetic induction rather than radio...

In case you're still weighing the alternatives, take a look at these wireless technologies competing with Bluetooth in the personal area network (PAN) space:

Induction Wireless: This technique uses magnetic induction rather than radio for close-range communications. In radio, both electric and magnetic fields make up the signal, while in induction wireless, only the magnetic field is transmitted. The transmitter is a radiating coil that's more like the primary winding of a transformer than an antenna.

Invented and patented by Aura Communications (www.auracomm.com), this system has about a 3-m range. A typical unit transmits up to 204.8-kbit/s data rates via GMSK modulation on 11.5 MHz. Its key benefits are extremely low power consumption, low cost, and the inherent security that accompanies short range.

Infrared Wireless: This was probably the first PAN technology for use over short distances. The IrDA infrared (IR) standard appeared during the early 1990s, thanks to Hewlett-Packard, and it is still supported by Agilent Technologies (www.agilent.com). IrDA initially offered a 115.2-kbit/s data rate over a range of up to 1 m. A 4-Mbit/s version was soon developed and has been widely incorporated in laptops and PDAs for printer connections and short-range PANs. A 16-Mbit/s version is available too.

The problem with IrDA isn't just its very short range, but also its need for a line-of-sight (LOS) connection. Of course, Bluetooth doesn't need LOS, and it can blast through walls. A more recent IR development is IrGate, which was produced by Infra-Com Technologies (www.infra-com.com). It uses arrays of high-powered IR LEDs to emit coded baseband IR in all directions. Then it relies on an array of photodetectors and super-sensitive receivers to pick up the diffused IR within the networking space. Thus, the LOS problem is mitigated, and a data rate of up to 10 Mbits/s is possible.

Ultra Wideband: UWB transmits data by way of baseband pulses applied directly to the antenna. The narrow pulses (less than 1 ns) create an extremely broad bandwidth signal. The pulses are modulated by pulse position modulation (PPM) or binary phase-shift keying (BPSK). The FCC permits UWB in the 3.1- to 10.6-GHz band. Its primary application to date has been short-range, high-resolution radar and imaging systems that penetrate walls, the ground, and the body. In addition, this new technology is useful for short-range LANs or PANs that require very high data rates (over 100 Mbits/s). UWB is still new in the commercial and consumer world, but it's well known in military and government applications. New UWB products are expected soon.

ZigBee: A simpler, slower, lower-power, lower-cost cousin of Bluetooth, ZigBee (www.zigbee.org) was created by Philips. It's supported by a mix of companies that are targeting the consumer and industrial markets. It may be a better fit with games, consumer electronic equipment, and home-automation applications than Bluetooth. Short-range industrial telemetry and remote control are other target applications.

Previously called RF-Lite, ZigBee is like Bluetooth because it uses the 2.4-GHz band with frequency-hopping spread-spectrum with 25 hops spaced every 4 MHz. The basic data rate is 250 kbits/s, but a slower 28-kbit rate is useful for extended range and greater reliability. With a 20-dBm power level, ZigBee can achieve a range of up to 134 meters at 28 kbits/s. It additionally lets you network up to 254 nodes. While no chips are yet available, ZigBee bears watching.

Sponsored Recommendations

Understanding Thermal Challenges in EV Charging Applications

March 28, 2024
As EVs emerge as the dominant mode of transportation, factors such as battery range and quicker charging rates will play pivotal roles in the global economy.

Board-Mount DC/DC Converters in Medical Applications

March 27, 2024
AC/DC or board-mount DC/DC converters provide power for medical devices. This article explains why isolation might be needed and which safety standards apply.

Use Rugged Multiband Antennas to Solve the Mobile Connectivity Challenge

March 27, 2024
Selecting and using antennas for mobile applications requires attention to electrical, mechanical, and environmental characteristics: TE modules can help.

Out-of-the-box Cellular and Wi-Fi connectivity with AWS IoT ExpressLink

March 27, 2024
This demo shows how to enroll LTE-M and Wi-Fi evaluation boards with AWS IoT Core, set up a Connected Health Solution as well as AWS AT commands and AWS IoT ExpressLink security...

Comments

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Electronic Design, create an account today!