Dostal's Designs: Use Switching Surge Stoppers for Prolonged Overvoltages

May 9, 2024

Rather than use linear surge stoppers for overvoltage protection, opt for switching surge varieties, as the load will continue running even when surges last for a long time.

Frederik Dostal,

William G. Wong

Related To: Analog Devices

This video/article is part of Dostal's Designs series in Ideas for Design and the TechXchange: Power Supp ly Design. You can also post a question.

Members can download this article in PDF format.

What you'll learn:

Linear vs. switching surge stoppers.
An input protection circuit featuring an LTC4380.
Protection circuit design using a switching surge stopper.

Reliable industrial electronics often have protection circuits to head off any overvoltages on the supply lines and protect the electronics from damage. Overvoltages can arise when fast load changes occur on the power-supply line. Parasitic line inductance may result in high voltage spikes.

This issue can be addressed with an input protection circuit like that shown in Figure 1, which integrates an LTC4380 from Analog Devices. Power switch M1 is in the conductive path. If an overvoltage occurs at V_IN, switch M1 is operated in the linear region. It causes M1 to behave as a resistor in the ohmic region, allowing V_OUT to be regulated by the voltage drop across MOSFET M1.

1. Overvoltage protection with a linear surge protector IC (simplified circuit).

In turn, it prevents the output voltage from rising to excessively high levels, thereby protecting downstream electronics. This method is effective within a certain time limit. The duration is determined by the permissible safe operating area (SOA) of switch M1. However, if the voltage drop across the power MOSFET remains high and the duration exceeds the limit, the MOSFET will heat up beyond its maximum temperature threshold and become damaged.

Integrated circuits such as the LTC4380 have built-in timers to protect against overvoltages. The amount of time that the MOSFET operates in the linear region in an overvoltage situation is set on the timer. This time is usually on the order of a few milliseconds or microseconds. Once the set time has elapsed, switch M1 is completely shut off. As a result, the switch is protected, but the power supply to the system also shuts off.

Integrating a Switching Surge Protector

To ensure reliable operation and uninterrupted power supply to industrial electronics under all circumstances, it’s crucial to choose a solution that can tolerate overvoltage for extended periods. This includes considering fault scenarios such as incorrectly connected supply lines that may result in overvoltage. By selecting a solution that can handle these situations, the circuit can operate reliably and avoid disruptions to the supply voltage. This can be realized with a switching surge protector (Fig. 2).

2. This switching overvoltage protection circuit has no time limit for overvoltage (simplified circuit).

In addition to the surge protector IC, the circuit uses an inductor and an external Schottky diode. Basically, a step-down (buck) switching regulator is operated as a protective circuit. However, this switching regulator only begins to work when the input voltage exceeds a set maximum value. Operation in this time period typically doesn’t have to be particularly power-efficient. A simple Schottky diode can be used as a flyback diode.

Figure 3 shows an input voltage response in blue. The normal input voltage is 16 V. At approximately 2 ms, an overvoltage reaching 40 V occurs. The change in output voltage over time is shown in red. For the duration of the V_IN overvoltage, the switching DC-DC regulator is activated to regulate the output voltage to 16 V. The switching node voltage (at the node between the MOSFET, the Schottky diode, and the inductor) is shown in green.

3. Input voltage and output voltage response to overvoltage (top) and switching at the switching node in the high-frequency range (bottom).

An overvoltage protection circuit can thus be designed linearly as shown in Figure 1 or with a special switching (buck) DC-DC regulator like the LTC7860 in Figure 2. A simple step-down switching regulator isn’t suitable for this application because the N-channel MOSFET can’t be continuously on in this case.

Overvoltage protection circuits include both linear surge protectors and switching surge protector ICs. The latter allows for continuous operation of a circuit even during a lengthy overvoltage event. This means that the circuit to be powered is continuously protected and operational, even when overvoltages last a long time.

Give More Thought to Component Selection

More and more industrial and instrumentation applications require precision converters to accurately control and measure various processes. In addition, these end applications demand increased flexibility, reliability, and feature sets, while simultaneously reducing costs and board area. Component manufacturers are addressing these challenges and offering a number of products to address the needs of system designers for current and future designs.

As can be gleaned from this article, many different approaches can be taken to select the right components for precision applications, each offering their own associated drawbacks and benefits. As the accuracy of the system increases, more thought needs to be put into the selection of the right component to suit the application needs.

About the Author

Frederik Dostal | Power-Management Technical Expert

Frederik Dostal is a power-management expert with more than 20 years of experience in this industry. After his studies of microelectronics at the University of Erlangen, Germany, he joined National Semiconductor in 2001, where he worked as a field applications engineer, gaining a lot of experience in implementing power-management solutions in customer projects. During his time at National, he also spent four years in Phoenix, Arizona (USA), working on switch-mode power supplies as an applications engineer.

In 2009, he joined Analog Devices, where since then he held a variety of positions working for the product line and European technical support, and currently brings in his broad design and application knowledge as a power-management expert. Frederik works in the ADI office in Munich, Germany.

Also check out my:

About the Author

William G. Wong | Senior Content Director - Electronic Design and Microwaves & RF

I am Editor of Electronic Design focusing on embedded, software, and systems. As Senior Content Director, I also manage Microwaves & RF and I work with a great team of editors to provide engineers, programmers, developers and technical managers with interesting and useful articles and videos on a regular basis. Check out our free newsletters to see the latest content.

You can send press releases for new products for possible coverage on the website. I am also interested in receiving contributed articles for publishing on our website. Use our template and send to me along with a signed release form.

Check out my blog, AltEmbedded on Electronic Design, as well as his latest articles on this site that are listed below.

You can visit my social media via these links:

I earned a Bachelor of Electrical Engineering at the Georgia Institute of Technology and a Masters in Computer Science from Rutgers University. I still do a bit of programming using everything from C and C++ to Rust and Ada/SPARK. I do a bit of PHP programming for Drupal websites. I have posted a few Drupal modules.

I still get a hand on software and electronic hardware. Some of this can be found on our Kit Close-Up video series. You can also see me on many of our TechXchange Talk videos. I am interested in a range of projects from robotics to artificial intelligence.