Electronic Music Hell


We speculated that most small bands probably spent more time actually setting up and tearing down their gear than they ever did performing.

I was sitting in Greune Hall, the oldest (1854) dance hall in Texas drinking a cold Lone Star longneck and contemplating what music would be like without electronics.  It was 101 degrees outside and the twelve ceiling fans were just barely keeping up with the heat in this ancient wooden building.  Most famous country music stars have played here at one time or another along with hundreds maybe thousands of not-so-famous local bands.  It is the kind of place that bikers favor but also one where you can bring the kids if you want.  Today I have seen all ages from 4 to probably near 80 walking around or dancing.  You can still get a cold beer here for only $2.50 and there is no smoking.

My wife and I were watching a Cajun band tear down and pack their equipment.  We speculated that most small bands probably spent more time actually setting up and tearing down their gear than they ever did performing.  Besides the guitars, keyboards, drums, and other instruments there are lots of electronic pieces like speakers, microphones, amplifiers, mixers, percussion effects, monitors and cables.  Always lots of cables.  It is a major process to pack, unpack, set up and tear down each time you perform but you can’t not do it.  The electronics has become the backbone of the music business.

We watched the Cajun band drive away in a 1970s era travel van.  Then one beer later, we watched another local band set up.  It took just about an hour and several beers for them to unload, place, connect and test their set up.  And then they began to play.  After three sets and lots of audience dancing and more beers later, the band reversed the ritual and started tearing down and repacking making space for the next band.  That is what I am calling electronic music hell.  And it is universal and affects small bands as well as the big stars with their major sets, sound systems, light shows and special effects.  Big stars travel with multiple 18-wheelers to haul the stage gear.  Set up and teardown is hell for the full time roadies that do the grueling work.

But can you imagine music without the electronics?  Big amps and speakers are a major part of any music venue.  Furthermore you need a major mixing console to blend all the mikes and instruments into the unique sounds of the performers.  Today light shows are a huge part of the show.  Multicolor lights, flashing lights, spots and rotating lights plus lasers are common.  Think of all the computers, programming , and electronics involved in that process.  In addition, most shows also feature one or more monster HD video screens so fans far away from the action can see what is going on.  No electronics, no show.

The electronics for music concerts has become a big business.  With CD sales way down and streaming music growing, big stars and bands are relying more today on touring for major income.  And that means lots of electronic gear.  Banks of big speakers, multimillion dollar computer-controlled light shows and huge video screens.  It is a multi-billion dollar industry that keeps the likes of Katy Perry and Lady Gaga supplied with all the special effects their acts demand to keep them competitive and the fans coming back for more.  Dozens of companies like Clair Brothers and Tait Towers serve this need.  Most of them are clustered in the unlikely Amish country town of Lititz, PA.  Recently the industry built a 52,000 square foot rehearsal building in Lititz where stars can set up, tweak and test their stages in secret.  It is electronic heaven to the stars that increasingly rely on fancy effects in addition to their musical talent.  But it is electronic hell for those who transport, build, test, operate and tear down such gear.  Thank goodness for cold beer.

Discuss this Blog Entry 9

on Aug 26, 2014

Lou: Nice blog. But I would wager that most of those roadies, techs, and engineers who "transport, build, test, operate and tear down such gear," are happy for the job. They hardly think of it as Hell. If they do, it's Hell with a great soundtrack.

on Aug 27, 2014

This piece made me think of Jackson Browne's "The Load-Out" (segueing into "Stay"). Also, you should read the WSJ piece about Lititz, PA.

on Aug 27, 2014

As someone who's 'been there, done that', the setup and teardown is not the hell. The real hell is malfunctioning equipment, cables breaking and, above all, ground loops.

on Aug 27, 2014

First of all you ought to at least make a distinction between the instruments (many of which are electronic) which the band MUST supply, and the sound reinforcement, which the band usually gets into the habit of supplying because the "house system" is generally so deplorable! (There's also something called "foldback" so the musicians can hear themselves which could fall into either category.) The reputation of the band (thus its ability to book future gigs) depends on how it sounds on stage so can you blame the band for bringing that too? (It's borderline comical how some bands get booked into a huge venue like a stadium and are expected to bring enough gear to be heard WELL throughout, unless you're a MAJOR act that premise is just insane but some show producers try and get away with it.) Over time this situation just seems to get worse, I understand instead of getting paid the acts for the halftime for this year's Superbowl may in fact be asked to pay a fee for the "privilege of exposure", I wonder where this is all going NEXT?

on Aug 30, 2014

I have a lot to say on the open-ended question of imagining music without electronics.

For me, electronics (hardware) serves only one basic function in music, and that is to be able to address a larger audience. Removing it in my opinion would simply drive the music trend Backwards. Electronics (software) also serves only one basic function in music, and that is to reproduce unique sounds. Since sound waveforms can easily be manipulated (for example, by Matlab),there are endless possibilities to the kinds of sounds you can reproduce (specially when you're equipped with a background of signal processing algorithms).

To get an idea of the challenges acoustics engineers face (and why Mr. Frenzel would refer to it as hell), the study of predictability of sound over an enclosed surface is still vague (not to mention open areas). An acoustic engineer has to cover as much audience area as possible without sacrificing the intensity (volume). Only a few rules of thumb exist in acoustics engineering.

Personally, I love listening to classical music but I sometimes prefer playing them myself over listening to them (because somehow, you would be able to express/feel a stronger flow of emotion). Lately, I've grown fond of trailer music because of its upbeat style.

on May 27, 2015

Ah, but you're missing a major segment of electronics in music when you think "electronics (hardware) serves only one basic function in music, and that is to be able to address a larger audience". There are many electronic-only instruments, often with keyboards. There are several electronics effects boxes that can be attached to guitars. Computers are used to replicate and repeat sounds to multiply the effects of lone performers. If you really want to go "far out" there are specialty instruments like the Theremin. And I suspect that I'm leaving stuff out.

Even classical orchestras may utilize occasional electronic instruments. Popular musicians almost can't perform without electronics. So even if you prefer classical music, it is always interesting to expand one's horizons.

on Sep 30, 2016

Timely that I come across this blog today, as tomorrow I am heading to the "dozenth" annual L.A. Amp Show, where manufacturers of guitar amplifiers, musicians, and the like get together to try out the wares. As it's a 72-mile drive from my house, I don't go every year, but I have been going every 2 or 3 years since the show started in 2005, and it's a total blast! Electronic music heaven, for sure! Guitar signal amplification and modification is big business, and it's a heck of a lot of fun. Unlike the NAMM show, the Amp Show is held in a place where there are no volume limitations, so the vacuum tube monster amps can be cranked up to where the tone really gets great and the bass notes thump you in the chest! There is just nothing like that visceral sensation of a room-filling tube amp! I am salivating at the thought of tomorrow's show, but probably packing up the gear after the show is yeah, hell for the participating vendors.

on Sep 30, 2016

@ferd and justinmamaradlo, speaking of classical music and electonics, I am reminded of a story in perhaps Electronic Musician magazine about an audio engineer who was told by a client to record a classical orchestra without any effects, totally dry. Well, the engineer knew enough not to take that literally and added just a touch of reverb to make the recording sound real. Too darn flat without it. Not to mention the recording electronics itself. Rare to find music being made without any electronics; even singer/songwriters with just an acoustic guitar may amplify the guitar sound and/or their voices.

on Sep 30, 2016

Chamber music. Mostly devoid of any electronics at all.

Even better if performed by the musicians for themselves--the idea of a bunch of friends getting together to make music for their own enjoyment.

Please or Register to post comments.

What's Communiqué?

Blogs on topics such as wired and wireless networking.


Lou Frenzel

Lou Frenzel writes articles and blogs on the wireless, communications and networking sectors for Electronic Design. Formerly, Lou was professor and department head at Austin Community College...
Commentaries and Blogs
Guest Blogs
Jan 26, 2017

An Amateur’s View on the P2 (Part 2): Slew Rate and the Oscillator 1

Justin Mamaradlo takes a further look into the P2 op amp and how it functions, analyzing the oscillation and slew-rate characteristics of the venerable component....More
Jul 15, 2016

Simple Yet Effective ESD Testing Methods for Higher Reliability 7

There are multiple ways to test for electrostatic discharge, ranging from implementing a human-body or machine model to....using a balloon and a comb?...More
Apr 8, 2016

Confabbing on the Fabless Fad 5

High capital and maintenance costs, and EDA advances along with abstractions to deal with chip complexity, have been leading contributors to the fabless migration....More

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×