Turn Everything Off or Be Regulated


Government agencies love to regulate.  After all, that’s what they do.  Sometimes the regulations are warranted, necessary and a good thing.  But many times they are not.  I get the feeling that these agencies are not busy enough so look for things to regulate.  That is too much of a good thing… if you can really call most regulations a “good thing”.

Just recently I was speaking with Anton Monk of Entropic, the chip company that makes the widely used MoCA home networking chips and set top box (STB) SoCs.  MoCA chips use the existing in-home cable TV coax wiring to distribute cable TV signals and Internet access to PCs, TVs, routers, and DVRs.  Monk explained that the Department of Energy (DoE) had recently decided to clamp down on STB manufacturers because of the high power consumption.  Most people leave their set top boxes on for a fast start when they turn on the TV set.  Even if the box is turned off, it is still technically on because it needs to be because it is connected to the cable network and gets its directions, software updates and new TV schedules during the night.  And you certainly don’t want to unplug the box as it will take a half hour or so to reboot it.  With millions of STBs in the U.S. each eating up 30 watts or so when on and maybe a fourth of that when “off”, that’s too much wasted power.

This situation is similar to the charger problem.  Most people leave their cell phone and other device chargers plugged in even when not charging.  These devices consume power even when not charging so are a constant drain on the grid.  Everyone should faithfully unplug their chargers when not using them.  I doubt that will ever happen.  The outcome is that charger manufacturers had to resort to different designs that consumed less power when plugged in but not charging.  This is a good thing as it must save a gazillion kilowatt/hours of energy during the year.  It may be possible to save even more if STBs were more power efficient.

Anyway, the DoE decided to back off from the original proposed regulations and told the industry to self regulate the power consumption of STBs.  The industry was required to submit such self regulation guidelines to the DoE by September 30th.  That was done by industry standards group Cable Labs.  The details are not known yet.  Hopefully the DoE will be happy with the self regulation details so that no formal regulations will be necessary.

Chip makers like Entropic have already taken steps to add power saving features like sleep and standby modes into their devices.  Most now incorporate a power management section that keeps specific circuits like processors and interfaces shut down unless they are being used.  Big power savings will result in the forthcoming generation of STBs and DVRs.

I wish the government would do more of the self regulation approach.  Who knows best how to control their products and technology than the manufacturers?

Newsletter Signup

Please or Register to post comments.

What's Communiqué?

Blogs on topics such as wired and wireless networking.


Lou Frenzel

Lou Frenzel is the Communications Technology Editor for Electronic Design Magazine where he writes articles, columns, blogs, technology reports, and online material on the wireless, communications...
Commentaries and Blogs
Guest Blogs
Nov 11, 2014

How to Outsource Your Project to Failure 4

This article will address failure to carefully vet a potential manufacturing or “turnkey” partner and/or failure to transfer sufficient information and requirements to such a partner, a very common problem I have seen again and again with my clients over the years, and have been the shoulder cried upon by several relatives and clients in the past....More
Nov 11, 2014

Transition from the Academe to the Industry Unraveled 1

There have been many arguments here and there about how short-comings of universities and colleges yield engineers with skill sets that do not cater to the demands of the industry. There have been many arguments here and there about an imminent shortage of engineers lacking knowledge in the sciences. There have been many arguments here and there about how the experience and know-how of engineers in the industry may vanish due to the fact that they can’t be passed on because the academic curriculum deviates from it....More
Nov 11, 2014

Small Beginnings 5

About 10 years ago I received a phone call from an acquaintance. He had found a new opportunity selling some sort of investments and he wanted to share it with me in case I was interested. Ken had done fairly well for many years as a contract software developer primarily in the financial services sector. His specialty was writing RPG code. (RPG is often referred to as a write only language.) But he was seeing the handwriting on the wall as the industry moved on to other methods, and saw himself becoming a fossil....More

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×